|
Post by grandad on Aug 18, 2007 7:50:11 GMT -5
hi all i would like to make a tuned length extractor for my sr and still pass blue slip ..probably with a stock harly silencer as they are as cheep as chips on ebay from what iv seen...can any one give me the formula....or a hint where to find it..any other sugestions apreciated............ thanks
|
|
|
Post by sjef on Aug 18, 2007 8:06:14 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by andy on Aug 19, 2007 11:48:13 GMT -5
hi sjef,i'm also interested in improved exhaust set-up but nothing happening on your thread?
|
|
|
Post by sjef on Aug 19, 2007 16:05:56 GMT -5
Hallo Andy look here www.nightrider.comsome where on this site you will find a calculator for nthe exhaustlength regards sjef
|
|
|
Post by wotavidone on Aug 19, 2007 17:35:55 GMT -5
Hmmm. This calcultor at nightrider might be OK if you have 7 0r 800 cc in you cylinder, like a Harley. Has anyone ever tried this trick told to me by an engine builder who was, before he fell victim to metal fatigue at 140 mph, very famous and well respected in South Oz speed boat racing? Apparently, you draw a line down your header/exhaust pipe with chalk. Take your boat for a hot lap or two. When you come back, your chalk line will be burnt to a certain point on your header. This is where you cut it off. Or maybe the line is done with soap. Memory fading. I'll check with my boat racing mates and get back to you. Mick When you come back
|
|
|
Post by sjef on Aug 19, 2007 18:02:54 GMT -5
Hallo
sportsters and the earley v twins were about 500cc /barrel
sjef
|
|
|
Post by colinjay on Aug 21, 2007 17:31:52 GMT -5
Hi,
In his book, "Performance Tuning in Theory and Practice" A. Graham Bell, gives the the following formula for determining the tune length for a exhaust header pipe;
Length = (850 x ED / rpm) - 3
ED = 180 degrees plus the number of degrees the exhaust valve opens before BDC rpm = revs at which max toruqe occours
In a table of calculations in the book, for an exhaust valve opening 75 Deg before BDC (the std SR cam is 76 Deg BBDC) the following lengths are listed;
Max torque rpm length
6000 33.1" 6500 30.4" 7000 28.0" 7500 25.9"
In the book he does not state it but these lengths are normally taken as being from the centre of the exhaust valve, not from the actual exhaust port / flange, so you have to deduct the length of the actual exhaust port from the pipe length.
The diameter of the pipe is calculated using a formula that I can't seen to type into the computer, but for a 33.1" long pipe, you use a pipe with a ID of 1.68" or the closest available pipe. Generally, altering the ID of the pipe will shift the max torque down about 500 rpm for a 0.125" reduction in diamater and up the same amount for a similar ID change.
The author also states that on at "standard" road tuned engine, an error of 10% in pipe length either way will only result in a bout a 3% power reduction from that with the optimum tune length. He also goes into the advantages and power gains that are possible with a tuned megaphone, which probably isn't applicable in you case as you want to remain road legal, and a pipe that I have made based on his work is even too loud for racing now days.
CJ
|
|
|
Post by wotavidone on Aug 21, 2007 17:48:35 GMT -5
Hmmm. That's the biggest question mark in my mind. You make the effort, even figuring out what length contribution you get from the exhaust valve, then you have to stick on a muffler to shut it all up enough to get the cops off your back. Throw in pipe diameter, materials (different ones have different pipe friction coefficients), gas temperatures, etc, and it all gets a bit tricky. The more I think about it, and after reading the how-to bit on their website, I reckon it would be hard to beat a Supertrapp. At least after doing all the other stuff, you can make some final adjustments in small increments. So, from the table, does max torque occur at 6000 rpm because you put the 33.1" pipe on, or does it mean you put a 33.1" pipe on because the engine specs say the max torque is at 6000rpm? What does he say about bends? You cut the length pipe you want, then bend it? Fascinating subject. Came across an article about tuning a TT500. Standard was 29 hp at back wheel at 6500. One particular pipe/carby combination gave 36hp at back wheel at 6500. That's nearly 25% gain for just pipe and carb. That gain required about 22 dyno runs. Also, being a TT500 in 1975, they probably did not let noise worry them too much. Sure would like to be able to bolt on an extra 25% without opening up the engine though. Mick
|
|
|
Post by colinjay on Aug 21, 2007 21:24:06 GMT -5
The pipe calculations are based on designing a pipe to give max torque at the rpm that you choose and use in the calculations. So you choose the rpm you want max torque, for a street engine, or max power for a race engine and calculate the length of the pipe for that rpm. The rpm that that max torque and/or HP ocours is based on the cam design and other things like the carbie etc as everything is so inter-related. The author makes no mention of the effect of bends on the power, but you wouls have to think that an "up" pipe with tight bends would mack a bit of a dofference compared to a "down" pipe with fewer and less tight bends.
When I have made pipes, and I think a lot of tuners do the same, I have made the header pipe a bit longer the tuned length and then cut it back as a bit of trial and error. Sometimes you actually have to make the pipe a bit longer than the tuned length so you can get the end to a position that you can actually fit a megaphone / muffler.
So in reality, it all gets a bit too technical unless you are chasing the absolute last little bit of HP out of an engine.
The small Supertrapp mufflers are actually very close in dimensions to the megaphones that suit the 500 Yamaha engine. From memory the last megaphone that I made for mine was about 180mm long, with a 7 degree taper, which as I said is close to the size of a Supertrapp. Since it was so loud, I ended up fitting a small Supertrapp, with about 18 plates in it to keep the noise nazi's of my back, although now even the Supertrapp would be too loud for racing with the new noise rules.
CJ
|
|
|
Post by wotavidone on Aug 21, 2007 21:43:07 GMT -5
Where did you get your supertrapp from? 18 plates would be a lot wouldn't it? Guy up here with a 1200 harley with 2 into 1 pipe is only running about 8 of the 4 inch plates. I guess I just like the concept of the Supertrapp, gives you something to adjust without getting your clothes greasy and sending the missus into a hissy fit. Mick
|
|
|
Post by wotavidone on Aug 21, 2007 21:45:41 GMT -5
PS. What do you bend your pipes with? The guys up here tell me that an ordinary hydraulic pipe bender like you could buy from say Catford Engineering in Jamestown, will just crimp thin wall exhaust pipe. I wondered about putting a spring over the pipe, like plumbers do with copper pipe.
|
|
|
Post by colinjay on Aug 21, 2007 22:07:40 GMT -5
I have had my suppertrapps ( 1 x 4" and a couple of 2" ones that I use on my race engines) since the late 70's, although I did pick one up at a swap meet a few years ago. I think Show & Go M/cycles on Brighton Rd in Adelaide still sell them, but don't hold me to that.
I have made up some rough / test pipes using tubing bent by the ordinary hydraulic benders, but when I make up good pipes, I have bought 90 degree mandrel bends from exhaust buisnesses and then "cut & shut" then too suit what I want. The pipe on my good cafe' racer was made this way from stainless tube that I bought from Staintune. I took an awfull lot of work to cut and weld the pipe then file and polish off all the welds to make it look good, but I wouldn't go that far for a race pipe.
The stailess header pipe on my "stock" SR was made up for me by Redline Exhaust in Adelaide as a copy of a pattern that I supplied. So if you made up a a "pattern" pipe using ordinary crimped bends, the guy at Redline would probably be able to replicate it.
CJ
|
|
|
Post by frankyb on Aug 22, 2007 2:10:08 GMT -5
Hi guys, the place where i get my tubing from supplies in mandrel bends with 5 degree increments from zero degrees to a full donut of variying radius. Build it on the bike piece by piece and you will get it exactly how you want it. On the reverse cone on megas, keep the angle as close to 22 degrees as you can get, as apparantly this is the optimum for back pressure issues. There is an old guy down the road from me who is a tank maker, and he has all the gear for rolling cones in sheet metal, takes all the guesswork out of making a megaphone. Also i believe that exhaust tube suppliers (in aus anyway) always work in outside diameter. Cheers Franky b.
|
|
|
Post by sjef on Aug 22, 2007 4:57:40 GMT -5
Hallo
pipe is always inside diameter tube is always outside diameter
regards sjef
|
|
lancer
New Member
There is no substitute for PERFORMANCE
Posts: 10
|
Post by lancer on Sept 19, 2007 1:00:59 GMT -5
If this is to be a road bike then try 32" for the tube length & 1.5" ID for tube diameter. That will give you good performance and will avoid tuning issues.
|
|